An Adexon white paper
Read time: 32 mins
The Adexon Technical team explain the important role of standards in ensuring the quality, safety, and performance of active fire curtains.
Table of Contents
BS 8524-1:2013 (hereinafter referred to as ‘BS 8524’) has been a popular product standard for fire curtains in the UK over the last decade.
However, following the harmonisation of BS EN 16034 on 1st November 2019, a European wide product standard that covers vertical fire curtains, BS 8524 could no longer be used for vertical fire curtains in the geographical areas signed up to the Construction Products Regulations 2013 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the CPR’). This includes the UK.
The harmonisation of BS EN 16034 meant it became a legal requirement to CE mark all vertical fire curtains to BS EN 16034. Please note, we are not referring to the very rare fire curtain fitted over window openings in our use of the words ‘vertical fire curtains’; window opening fire curtains are sufficiently rare as to not warrant being specifically called out.
Notified Bodies that previously supported BS 8524 subsequently withdrew support meaning the last third-party certification for BS 8524 expired on 9th June 2023.
An important context to this white paper is the commercial pressure being brought to bear on undermining the harmonised standard, BS EN 16034, so as to endeavour to keep BS 8524 in use.
In this white paper, we take you through these changes in detail.
2. Product standards
Product standards play a key role in ensuring that products of all types meet particular performance, quality, and safety standards. They are developed over many years by industry representatives who come together to agree on the appropriate requirements and testing procedures. This enables purchasers to understand what to expect from a product since it meets the requirements of a specific standard.
Product standards are made up of a series of complimenting product tests to form an ‘as-close-as-possible’ holistic assessment of the product in a real-life application. This is a big improvement from just testing a product to a single product test such as a fire test.
BS 8524 and BS EN 16034 are both examples of product standards that cover fire curtains, both comprising the following product tests: a fire test, a smoke test, and a cycle test, amongst other requirements.
Whilst standards can be very important and can make a significant contribution to consumer safety, regulations take precedence over them. As BSi tells us, “Compliance with a British Standard cannot confer immunity from legal obligations” and “standards aren’t the same as regulations and following a standard doesn’t guarantee that you’re within the relevant laws. In fact, standards rarely cite the law as legislation could change within the lifetime of the standard”.
If you are interested in reading more around regulations that apply to fire curtains, we have a comprehensive white paper on the subject, Fire curtain regulations in the UK1
Product standards for active fire curtains are no different to others – they set out performance requirements and put the products through a series of tests, enabling them to prove their performance. There are three main product standards that have been used over the last decade for active fire curtains in the UK:
- British standard BS 8524: 2013 Active fire curtain assemblies, Parts 1 and 2;
- International standard ISO 21524:2021: Requirements for active fire curtains; and
- European harmonised standard BS EN 16034: 2014 Pedestrian doorsets, industrial, commercial, garage doors and openable windows – Product standard, performance characteristics – Fire resisting and/or smoke control characteristics.
3. BS 8524
When the British Standard BS 8524 was published in 2013 it superseded the former fire-curtain specification, PAS 121:2007. Whilst it was a welcome improvement at the time there were still a number of deficiencies resulting in poor products being able to achieve BS 8524 and get to market. A recent survey at a £1bn office development in central London for a large global bank is a case-in-point3.
These deficiencies likely contributed to its demise, but it was really the European standard BS EN 16034 becoming harmonised on 1st November 2019 that signalled the end of BS 8524 for the foreseeable future, at least for vertical fire curtains.
The withdrawal of support for BS 8524 culminated in Warringtonfire and then IFCC pulling out from offering third-party certification for the standard. This resulted in the last valid third-party certification for BS 8524-1 expiring on 9th June 2023 meaning BS 8524 fire curtains should no longer be sold or purchased after that date.
In the future a new revised version of BS 8524 may be published, and this may regain Notified Body support but there is an indefinite and lengthy timeline. And these ‘maybes’ are presuming it can be justified that BS 8524 is not a ‘conflicting national standard’ with regards to BS EN 16034. If BS 8524 doesn’t overcome this ‘conflicting standard’ hurdle it will have to be formally withdrawn.
Thankfully the harmonised European standard BS EN 16034 that is legally required for vertical fire curtains is a comprehensive and current product standard that is fully supported with valid third-party certification from Notified Bodies. These certification schemes are accredited by the likes of UKAS.
This white paper is not advocating the use of BS 8524 by virtue of reviewing it. We believe BS 8524 should be formally withdrawn as it is a national standard that conflicts with BS EN 16034 for vertical fire curtains. You can read more about the work we have done on a revision of BS 8524 should it not be formally withdrawn in our article, BS 8524-1: A conflicting national standard that should be formally withdrawn – and the improvements it needed21.
4. Two Parts of BS 8524
BS 8524 consists of two separate parts.
BS 8524-1: 2013 Active fire curtain assemblies – Specification, is related to the product itself and outlines requirements for the design, testing and classification of the fire curtains. It brings together a number of complimenting tests (and some not-so-complimentary tests). We have submitted to BSI that if BS 8524 is to have a future version, some of the less desirable and arguably dangerous tests should be removed.
BS 8524-2: Active fire curtain barrier assemblies. Code of practice for application, installation and maintenance, recognises that the maintenance of fire curtains throughout their lifetime is important. It is a code of practice and it is misleading to say, “BS 8524 Part 2 has third-party approval” implying it is a unique benefit of BS 8524. There is a third-party approval scheme for the installation of fire curtains run by the IFCC called SDI 05 ‘Fire And Smoke Curtains (Active Or Passive)’. This is available for fire and smoke curtain products certified to the standards BS EN 16034, BS 8524-1 (when it had valid certification), and ISO 21524.
A significant element of Part 2 is the same text on regular checks that you will find in the manufacturer’s Operation & Maintenance manual to help comply with the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 (the ‘FSO 2005’). These include what should be done regularly on site, and those actions that are less frequent and must be undertaken by a competent engineer.
An example is the advice to check for obstructions that might prevent the curtain from deploying, such as alterations to cosmetic finishes, lighting, shelving or racking, furniture or temporary displays. However, the most common obstructions we find preventing deployment are within the design used for BS 8524 fire curtains themselves. The older designs used on BS 8524 fire curtains use a smoke seal or rubber draft excluder to provide smoke control. These are prone to becoming detached and blocking the side guide. See this case-in-point3.
5. Third-party approval of installation and the FSO 2005
The SDI 05 installation scheme offers specifiers and fire authorities a degree of confidence that the product’s installation as a life-safety device is competently carried out. There are specified requirements for installation although these are not comprehensive and the most reliable method for ascertaining correct installation remains the actual testing of the product at the point of commissioning, and then each week, in the same manner as it would be required in a fire.
A legal requirement of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 (the ‘FSO 2005’) is that life-safety products such as fire curtains “are subject to a suitable system of maintenance and are maintained in an efficient state, in efficient working order and in good repair”. Essentially, if it works each week on the tests and this is recorded, this is more reliable evidence of ‘working order and good repair’ than historic installation paperwork.
We have encountered end-users not carrying out weekly testing of their fire curtains due to recurring jamming issues they are experiencing. This can be traced back to certain designs of older fire curtains4. Regardless of installation paperwork, if the product doesn’t work when tested it isn’t fit-for-purpose in its current state and needs urgently looking at by a specialist. If not, the Responsible Person risks breaching the legal requirements of the FSO 2005 and this is critically more important than any code of practice, however well-intentioned.
It is also important to note that the SDI 05 installer scheme does not check the manufacture of the product so should only be used as the ‘icing on the cake’ for fire curtains that already have valid third-party product certification. If the product supplied is potentially different to the test specimen, it matters not how well installed it is. Valid third-party product certification is your ‘insurance policy’ that the product supplied is the same as the test specimen.
Whilst the SDI 05 scheme recommends the fire curtain should be operated at least monthly, and on escape routes weekly, Adexon advocates all fire curtains are tested weekly along with other life-safety equipment such as the fire alarm. Where the fire curtain forms part of a smoke control system protecting a means of escape, it should be tested in conjunction with the smoke control system.
These weekly tests, as outlined in the manufacturer’s Operation & Maintenance manual, include the self-closing devices, automatic release mechanisms via a test switch, the sensory detection equipment, and self-test facility.
The take-away here is that third-party approval of the code of practice for installation is fine to have so long as it doesn’t create a false sense of security or complacency that the paperwork is a substitute for a reliably working fire curtain.
6. The tests and annexes within the standards
Like the other standards, BS 8524 tests the product for fire resistance and other aspects of the parts that make up the finished assembly. This includes the fabric curtain, motor drive, frame, electrical power and control systems and associated ancillary devices. It requires a series of operational tests to be undertaken prior to testing on the furnace. These ensure the components all work independently of each other. To read about these in more detail and to see a full technical comparison of BS 8524 with BS EN 16034, read the Adexon white paper, A technical comparison of BS EN 16034 and BS 85242.
BS 8524 includes annexes of mixed value. These are:
Annex A (normative) Overlapping multiple barriers.
This explains that the values for the minimum width of the end curtain and the minimum width of the overlap are calculated based on values recorded during the fire test. We believe it is important for the consumer to be able to check the amount of overlap tested and that this is related to the height (drop) of the fire curtain. It is obvious that a higher curtain would require more overlap. For example, 1m of overlap may suffice for a 2.2mH fire curtain but it is highly unlikely it would suffice on a 10mH fire curtain. This critical information is not available under BS 8524.
Annex B (normative) Order of testing.
This defines the order of testing for each specimen.
Annex C (normative) General requirements for testing.
This includes dimensions, fixing methods, joints, and seams etc. Unfortunately, little to none of this information is displayed in the publicly available BS 8524 documentation leaving it to the manufacturers to disclose what they feel best. Conversely, in the BS EN 16034 third-party certification from Applus, the end-user is provided with a mandatory ‘Technical Annexe’ covering extensive details that are critically important to the performance of the product.
Annex D (normative) Test method for barrier assembly reliability and response time and the durability of materials
Whilst this annex states that the barrier assembly must be tested for its reliability and response time using the control system with which it is intended to be used, there are no publicly available details of what was tested meaning you could get something different to what was tested.
This was one of the critical shortcomings of BS 8524 and its paperwork and was compounded by BS 8524 losing Notified Body support on 9th June 2023 meaning there is now also no valid third-party certification available for it. You can read more about how important this is for risk in the Adexon article, How valid third-party certification reduces your risk to close to zero6.
The annexe also requires the specimen to be tested in the orientation intended for use by the manufacturer. The downside to this is that there is no publicly available documentation to tell the consumer (or even the installers) what this orientation is meaning it could be installed the wrong way around, sitting with its untested side to the fire which could have fatal consequences.
The reliability and durability testing simulates the usage of the curtain, with the required 500 cycles representing one test each week for 10 years. This cycle test is required in all three of the abovementioned standards, but the aspiration to cycle test before the fire test shows the fabric still provides a fire barrier after years of use. The caveats/ limitations to the benefit of this are:
- the same curtain fabric being used for both tests, including the full and same size e.g. only part of the curtain fabric that was cycle tested may be used in the fire test.
- installation in ‘real-life’ being as good as and the same as the tests.
- not testing the areas of the curtain where the most common cause of wear, tear and ripping in curtains happens i.e. around the retention bolts/ poppers (where still used). It renders the ‘cycle test before fire test’ of negligible value if the fabric tearing issues the old designs are susceptible to are not fire tested. Watch the following short video to see the difference between the old designs and the newer designs. The newer designs are tested to BS EN 16034 and ISO 215244.
Similar to BS EN 1192, Annex D requires the barrier assembly to be tested for impact. This simulates a body colliding or falling into the closed curtain, which is important when the curtain is used along an escape route. A 50kg soft weight is dropped against the face of the curtain (at two different heights) with an impact energy of 100Nm prior to cycling the curtain for 500 operations. At the end of cycling, the curtain is subjected to the impact test again and the curtain is checked for damage. Whilst this seems a helpful test in theory, when we see what still happens to curtains that have passed this test it raises questions as to the effectiveness of the testing criteria. You can read more about what happens and why in our article, The quiet transformation happening in the fire curtain industry22.
Annex E (normative) Test method for motors
The motor reliability and durability testing has little safety benefit as fire curtains tested to any of the abovementioned standards have to deploy under gravity (without the motor working). The motor is tested to lift a weight equating to 90% of the maximum load, over a distance of 3m before it is released. There is a universal classification given to the number of cycles attained: C1 for 500 cycles, C2 for 10,000 cycles, C3 for 50,000 cycles.
Annex F (normative) Calculation of ambient temperature smoke leakage.
For more in-depth information about smoke testing, read ‘The science behind cold smoke seals’<sup8 and ‘Are cold smoke seals in a fire a cause for concern?’9.
Annex G (normative) Test method for the reliability of motor operation at elevated temperatures.
This test is carried out by placing a motor specimen in a furnace and operating it at maximum load following a prescribed timeline heat curve for a specified number of cycles. Elevated temperature testing of motors provides evidence that the motor will continue to function during the start of a fire, allowing the fire curtain to be retracted to release anyone trapped or for the Fire and Rescue Service to pass under the curtain. In theory, this could be seen as a good test, as it demonstrates the robustness of the curtain’s control mechanism, even under extreme conditions.
However, in practice, a fire curtain should never be operable if there are temperatures of anything approaching the upper limit tested of 400°C on one side, as this would pose a severe-to-fatal risk to the operator and could allow the fire to pass beyond the designated compartmentation barrier and thus endanger the whole building. You can read more about this in the technical comparison white paper already referred to, and the Adexon article, The dangers of the hot motor test in BS 8524-1:201318
Annex H (normative) Test method for ancillary and optional equipment
Annex I (informative) Typical product performance summary
The annexes and test methods are intended to show the performance of the product in use. However, without valid third-party certification for BS 8524 there is no longer any independent inspection and auditing by a Notified Body to ensure the product reaching site is the same as the tested specimen.
7. Will BS 8524 achieve valid third-party certification again?
No one could provide indemnify against a date when third-party certification will be available again for BS 8524 due to the uncertain future it faces and the indefinite and lengthy process before valid third-party certification for BS 8524 could be available again. The high level view of the process is:
- BS 8524 needs revising
- Notified Bodies then need to create a scheme that can be assessed and accredited e.g. by UKAS
- Manufacturers then need to pass the new tests in BS 8524 including the European standards fire test
- Then certification, audits, paperwork, and Factory Production Control needs to be completed
If BS 8524 achieved third-party certification again it will still be a legal requirement to CE mark all vertical fire curtains to BS EN 16034. The foreword of the harmonised standard, BS EN 16034, states, This European Standard [BS EN 16034] shall be given the status of a national standard… and conflicting national standards shall be withdrawn at the latest by October 2019”. This won’t change until BS EN 16034 changes, the CPR changes, or BS 8524 becomes harmonised. None of these are likely within the next five years, if ever (BS 8524 is highly unlikely to ever become harmonised).
8. A future for BS 8524-1?
BS 8524 was a good start to a dedicated product standard for fire curtains when it was published in 2013. The international standard ISO 21524 builds on the good within BS 8524, providing long term scope for a dedicated fire curtain product standard without the weaknesses seen in BS 8524. There is still a lot of work to be done with ISO 21524 as several of the deficiencies of BS 8524 have been incorporated to date. Adexon are now on the BSI National Committee that contributes to ISO 21524 so will be working with the rest of the committee to make these improvements on the next publication.
The big question with regards to BS 8524 is that it remains to be seen if it has a future. Key factors are that it is neither harmonised nor internationally recognised. The market in the UK is relatively small, fire curtains are a niche product, and it is a question as to whether it is financially viable for Notified Bodies to run certification schemes for a ‘nice-to-have’ standard such as BS 8524 that can only be used in a comparatively small geographical market when they can run schemes for BS EN 16034 (a harmonised standard legally required5 under the CPR and with European wide appeal) and/or ISO 21524 which has international reach. It would seem that IFCC and Warringtonfire concluded BS 8524 was not viable to continue supporting, with or without its deficiencies, otherwise it would stand to reason they would have resourced themselves accordingly and stood with it whilst it underwent revision.
Without valid third-party certification from a Notified Body, BS 8524 loses its main benefit of independent inspections and audits that ensure the products reaching site, and the components, are the same as those that were tested originally.
In conclusion, even ignoring the requirement for BS 8524 to be formally withdrawn as being a conflicting national standard to BS EN 16034, the odds are stacked against BS 8524 coming back even from commercial and common sense perspectives, having no regulatory mandate, a better and newer competitor that appeals to all the international markets (ISO 21524), and for the foreseeable future the harmonised standard BS EN 16034 being legally required for all vertical fire curtains (circa 90% of the total fire curtain market).
9. ISO 21524 fire curtain standard
As already mentioned, ISO 21524 is an international standard for fire curtains that some say is the long-term future for all configurations of fire curtains. However, like BS 8524, it is not harmonised so cannot be used for vertical fire curtains in the UK or EU markets.
ISO 21524 also has no third-party certification scheme for concertina fire curtains meaning it is currently limited to horizontal fire curtains. It could be used for concertina fire curtains if a Notified Body creates a certification scheme for them. Concertina fire curtains currently have third-party certification schemes available to BS EN 16034 and, due to the size of the market and the financial viability of competing schemes with very little demand, it would seem there is no appetite from Notified Bodies to create an ISO 21524 third-party certification scheme for concertina fire curtains.
Improvements required to ISO 21524 include removing features of questionable value and safety such as pass doors and vision panels. Neither feature makes sense practically or for safety. You can read a detailed appraisal of these in our article, BS 8524-1: A conflicting national standard that should be formally withdrawn – and the improvements it needed21, as these features originated from BS 8524. Below we include a brief overview.
Pass doors in fire curtains have a number of issues ranging from the trip hazard threshold (bottom bar) to the panic-accentuated user problem that occurs trying to undo the Velcro in a fire escape situation; it is much simpler and safer to use an ERB (emergency retract button). ERBs will retract the curtain for a preset time – if it is safe to do so. This latter point is very important as there is no way to stop someone from opening a Velcro pass door if there is a fire on the other side which could be very dangerous or even fatal to the user and endanger the whole building. Conversely, an ERB can be micro-switched to thermal and smoke sensors that prevent activation if either is present on the other side of the curtain.
Reference to vision panels should be removed altogether in the standards. Current designs of vision panel are manufactured from a combination of silicone on a silica fabric glass substrate. This clouds up at circa 300°C which is only seconds into a fire (refer to the heat curve in BS EN 1363, Fig. 1 which shows the temperature is 576°C after only 5 minutes). This means vision panels are opaque before emergency services reach them – even if they were going to rely on a small square of visibility to make decisions about entering a room or not.
Even if vision panels remained transparent for any length of time, they are of negligible value when rooms are filled with smoke. Thermal and smoke sensors can advise the fire services centrally as to the presence of smoke and/or fire, and it is negligent to recommend that a room-sweep check for people needing to escape is done courtesy of a small grainy window in the fire curtain. If it is safe to enter then the ERB should be used to enable a thorough check before resealing the room.
Simply put, vision panels in fire curtains are a gimmick. Including them in the standard risks implying value which may subsequently be used to sell them, or it may lead specifiers and buyers to believe they are providing a higher level of safety to their clients by including them when in reality they will be paying for nothing of value. A product standard should lead to and encourage best practices for fire safety.
ISO 21524 also introduces a new idea of repairing patches to tears in the fabric. This is not advisable as there is no third-party control over the quality of repair on site. This is not best practice for a life safety product that relies on the integrity of the curtain to perform and save lives. Additionally, this idea does not solve the root cause of most fabric tears and further tears will recur over time if the root cause is not resolved.
The root cause for fabric tearing in most cases is an old design that is still in use by some manufacturers. This design uses bolts or poppers punctured through the edges of the fabric to retain the fabric in the side guides (see Fig 2). This causes a weakness in the fabric together with a point load. Over time this frequently leads to a tear under the strain of regular testing. It happens even more quickly when the bolts or poppers jam in the guides. The solution to these problems is found in new designs of fire curtains that will soon be the norm for all manufacturers. Adexon does not advocate temporary and unreliable fabric patching in the meantime. Read more about the new design that solves the root cause of fabric tears, Simply put, it is better4.
If BS 8524 is not formally withdrawn and the revision includes unsafe tests and/ or gimmick features that are potentially unsafe or even dangerous, Adexon will recommend further revision. Life-safety is too important to shape standards around manufacturer’s products and instead, we manufacturers should up our game and lead the way in safety, with the standards simply providing the standardised benchmark for effective fire safety performance in real life.
10. Legal requirement
It is legally required to CE mark all vertical fire curtains to the harmonised European Standard BS EN 16034 since 1st November 2019. One of the improvements this has brought to the fire curtain industry is that BS EN 16034 only allows fire testing to the European fire test BS EN 1634-1 as opposed to BS 476. Conversely, BS 8524 has 30 references to BS 476 in it.
A fire curtain undertaking the European fire test has up to 30% more thermal exposure courtesy of the use of the plate thermometer. This means a 60-minute integrity fire curtain tested to BS 476 may fail after less than 45 minutes in the European fire test. As such a fire curtain tested to the British standard may fall well short of performance requirements where a fire strategy relies on the European Classifications e.g. E60. See more about this in our article, ‘Why scrapping BS 476 is good for safety’10.
BS EN 16034 is harmonised and thus comes under the CPR. You can read full details on it in the Adexon white paper, Fire curtain regulations in the UK1.
The application of BS EN 16034 to fire curtains was unsuccessfully challenged by those in favour of retaining BS 8524 back in 2018. You can see the details of this in this short video, The one reason why CE marking is legally required on all vertical fire curtains5.
You may have seen claims that the foreword of BS EN 16034 refers to BS 8524. This is inaccurate. It is the BSi national foreword that draws the reader’s attention to BS 8524. The national foreword is not part of the legally required harmonised standard text. BSi adds ‘front’ and ‘back’ covers when they publish European Standards, sometimes referring to British Standards such as in this case, but always adding the disclaimer in bold, “Compliance with a British Standard cannot confer immunity from legal obligations”. For added context, the BSI National Committee B/538 that wrote BSI’s national foreword on BS EN 16034 is largely the same members that created BS 8524.
‘Legal obligations’ include compliance with the CPR for construction products. Where a product is covered by a harmonised standard it has to be CE marked to that harmonised standard. In the case of vertical fire curtains, this means CE marking to BS EN 16034. The Adexon white paper, Fire curtain regulations in the UK1, goes over the subject in quite some detail.
You can also find an 8-minute video on our website going over the reasons some have cited for continuing to use BS 8524, Seven reasons cited for using BS 8524. Are they valid?11. This shows the ‘reasons’ don’t stand up to any level of scrutiny.
Some supporters of BS 8524 have tried to cite that harmonised product standard BS EN 16034 is used in conjunction with BS EN 13241-1:2003 + A2:2016 and that the latter does not specifically refer to fire curtains. There are two points that demonstrate this is an invalid argument. The first is simply that the Steering Group (GNB-CPR-SG06) set up for the standard considered the case and after deliberation reiterated that BS EN 16034 does cover fire curtains in conjunction with BS EN 13241-1:2003 + A2:2016. This meant that when it became harmonised on 1st November 2019 it became a legal requirement to CE mark to it.
The second point is about applications. It is plainly written in the scope of the harmonised standard, BS EN 16034, that the scope includes vertical fire curtains. Below is an extract and the full discussion and review of this can be found in the white paper, Every question answered: Do operable fabric curtains (fire curtains) need to be CE marked22
- pedestrian doorsets… etc…” and so on.
- A “doorset” is defined as a whole range of items including “rolling shutter and/ or operable fabric curtains including any frame or guide” or “rolling or folding curtain“.
- An “operable fabric curtain” is defined as a “doorset with leaf constructed from woven material… which functions as a rolling shutter“.
BS 8524 fire test reports to BS EN 1634-1 confirm fire curtains and operable fabric curtains are synonymous terms in the standards, the test reports being titled, ‘…for operable fabric curtains’.
For these reasons, citing ‘BS EN 13241-1:2003 + A2:2016 doesn’t refer specifically to fire curtains’ as a reason not to CE mark to BS EN 16034 is an example of dangerously misleading marketing for commercial gain. This behaviour has long been a source of ire and risk to the fire industry and Adexon feels a responsibility to provide the consumer with an in-depth analysis of such articles where it can, with accurate references to standards together with all relevant context so they are understood clearly for the sake of fire safety and legal compliance.
Those with a vested interest in BS 8524 may point to articles such as the Association for Specialist Fire Protection’s (ASFP’s), Technical Guidance Document (TGD) 21: UKCA / CE Marking of Operable Fabric Curtains12, which recommends that manufacturers wishing to CE mark operable fabric curtains seek further independent legal advice. What we need to understand is the context of this document (and others similar) that some Trade Bodies are there to support their members. It will come as no surprise that ASFP’s largest fire curtains members are keen supporters of BS 8524. ASFP are very transparent about this support for their members, and it can be seen in various documents on fire curtains by the ASFP whose members still manufacture primarily to BS 8524.
Another area where this support for members can be seen is in ASFP’s defence of BS 476 which suits their members’ products, even now calling for a longer transition period after the Building Safety Act proposed 12-months to transition. This is even though we have known in this country that these European Standards are superior and more thorough (safer) for over 20 years.
Prior to the Adexon white paper on fire curtain regulations, there had been over thirty articles, adverts and editorials published on fire curtains since BS EN 16034 became legally required on 1st November 2019. Thirty of the articles refer to BS 8524 and not one of them referred to BS EN 16034. Since Adexon first published the white paper, those authors have started to acknowledge the existence of the legal requirement to CE mark to BS EN 16034 for the first time whilst attempting to ‘piggy-back’ the third-party certification of BS EN 16034 by saying BS 8524 and BS EN 16034 are ‘complimenting’ standards i.e. have them both. This is not the case, for example, BS 8524 allows BS 476 as an option for fire testing whilst BS EN 16034 insists on only using the superior European Standard BS EN 1634-1 fire testing. Indeed, BS 8524 is what is termed a ‘conflicting national standard’ and under the CPR should be formally withdrawn21.
With the heavy promotion of BS 8524 it is not surprising that built environment professionals have been using the standard.
11. Conclusion: Where does BS 8524 now sit in the UK market for fire curtains?
BS 8524 no longer has valid third-party certification. No fire industry professional would advocate using a life-safety product without valid third-party certification unless they had a vested interest in saying so or there is no alternative. We can ignore vested interests and there is an alternative. Additionally, since 1st November 2019, it has been a legal requirement of the CPR to CE mark all vertical fire curtains to BS EN 16034. BS 8524 didn’t ever achieve harmonised status so cannot offer a route to legal compliance with the CPR. These two factors (legal compliance and third-party certification) mean BS 8524:
- should not be used for any vertical fire curtains since 1st November 2019
- should not be used for any fire curtains (vertical or concertina or horizontal) since 9th June 2023 when the last valid third-party certification for BS 8524 expired.
BS 8524 is often over-sold with claims of additional tests, and references to the installation code of practice. The reality is that a number of the ‘additional’ tests in BS 8524 are fads or even dangerous, and whilst the code of practice is a nice idea, the acid test for installation and commissioning is that the product works when it should i.e. the legal requirement of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 is that life-safety products such as fire curtains “are subject to a suitable system of maintenance and are maintained in an efficient state, in efficient working order and in good repair”. Unfortunately, BS 8524 products don’t always tick this box as can be seen with this case-in-point £1bn office development in central London for a large global bank3.
To read more about these refer to the earlier sections, Third-party approval of installation and the FSO 2005, and, The tests and annexes within the standards.
12. About the author:
We are at the forefront of valid third-party certification and legal compliance for fire and smoke curtains being the only company in the UK with third-party certification to a product standard (ISO 21524) for horizontal fire curtains and possibly the only company in the UK to have a third-party certified concertina smoke curtain to DH60.
This year alone we have been invited to talk at a number of prestigious events such as
- The Fire Safety Event13
- Chartered Association of Building Engineers (CABE) Conference Series
- CABE Salford – Built Environment England – Built Environment Series14
- CABE Cardiff – Built Environment Wales – Built Environment Series15
- Vision Construct 2023 | Royal Suite, Wembley Stadium | Construction conference and expo | Resibuild16
- Architects Journal Retrofit LIVE | September 2023 | 155 Bishopsgate, London24
- AJ Fire Safety Design 2023 | Virtual Conference25
- Build2Perform/CABE at Excel in Dec17
We have invested significantly over recent years to not only develop the UK’s premier design of active fire curtain4 but also in testing and certification, such that we have the widest range of legally compliant and third-party certified fire curtains in the UK.
The work we have done in raising awareness around critical safety performances of products has been recognised by the industry and we have recently been asked to join the below BSI National Committees to assess current standards and contribute to how they can be improved:
You can read some of our work with regards to BS 8524-1 in the article, BS 8524-1: A conflicting national standard that should be formally withdrawn – and the improvements it needed.21
This white paper was written by the team at Adexon Fire & Smoke in October 2023 and updated in December 2023. It includes the views of the Adexon team, and its intention is to raise awareness and standards in the fire curtain industry.
If you have a question for the team or would like to give feedback on this white paper or find out more, please get in touch.
We have a free RIBA CPD on active fire and smoke curtains, either in-person or online, you can book online19 (or contact us).
And/ or keep up to date on regulations and standards around fire curtains with our ‘Fire Safety Insights monthly newsletter20.
13. Additional Reading
For an example of going above and beyond legal compliance, read, ‘Are cold smoke seals in fire curtains a cause for concern?’9
If you are interested in impact testing, read why the design of the fabric retention and the durability of fire curtain designs is paramount, ‘Active fire curtain maintenance- and the 3 reasons fabric retention design matters’7
If you would like a deep dive read on the regulations applicable to fire curtains, you can find this in our white paper ‘Fire curtain regulations in the UK’1
1 Adexon Team (2023) Fire curtain regulations in the UK, Adexon Resources. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/fire-curtain-regulations-in-uk/ (Accessed: 30 June 2023).
2 Adexon Team (2023) A technical comparison of BS EN 16034 and BS 8524, Adexon Resources.
Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/technical-comparison-of-bsen16034-bs8524/ (Accessed: 30 June 2023).
3 Bigwood, T. (2023) Tom Bigwood on linkedin, Tom Bigwood on LinkedIn: #firesafety #firecurtains #smokecontrol. Available at: https://bit.ly/gsfcsurvey (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
4 Adexon Team (2023) Simply put, it is better., Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/it-is-better/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
5 Adexon Team (2023) The One reason why CE marking is legally required on all vertical fire curtains, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/why-ce-marking-is-legally-required/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
6 Adexon Team (2023) How valid third-party certification reduces your risk to close to zero, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/how-valid-third-party-certification-reduces-your-risk/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
7 Adexon Team (2023) Active fire curtain maintenance – and the 3 reasons fabric retention design matters, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/why-fabric-retention-design-on-fire-smoke-curtains-matters-a-lot/ (Accessed: 30 June 2023).
8 Adexon Team (2023d) The science behind cold smoke seals, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/science-behind-cold-smoke-seals/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
9 Adexon Team (2023) Are cold smoke seals in fire curtains a cause for concern? , Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/cold-smoke-seals-in-a-fire/ (Accessed: 30 June 2023).
10 Adexon Team (2023) Why scrapping BS476 is good for safety, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/why-scrapping-bs476-is-good-for-safety/ (Accessed: 28 July 2023).
11 Adexon Team (2023b) Seven reasons cited for using BS 8524. are they valid?, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/reasons-cited-for-using-bs8524/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
12 ASFP (no date) TGD 21 – Revision of CE UKCA advisory note – association for … , ASFP Technical Guidance Documents. Available at: https://asfp.org.uk/store/viewproduct.aspx?id=19779951 (Accessed: 30 June 2023).
13 Fire Safety Event (no date) Fire curtain compliance in the UK: The status quo of BS 8524 and BS EN 16034, The Fire Safety Event 2022. Available at: https://www.firesafetyevent.com/fire-safety-agenda-2023/fire-curtain-compliance-uk-status-quo-bs-8524-bs-en-16034 (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
14 CABE (2023) Built environment england, Built Environment Series. Available at: https://builtenvironmentseries.com/regional-conferences/england/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
15 CABE (2023b) Built environment wales, Built Environment Series. Available at: https://builtenvironmentseries.com/regional-conferences/wales/ (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
16 Vision construct 2023 | Royal Suite, Wembley Stadium | Construction Conference and expo | resibuild (2023) YouTube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GG4_cTg_168 (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
17 CABE (2023c) Build2Perform 2023. Available at: https://www.build2perform.co.uk/cabe (Accessed: 29 August 2023).
18 Adexon Team (2023) The dangers of the hot motor test in BS 8524-1:2013, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/articles/the-dangers-of-the-hot-motor-test/ (Accessed: 29 December 2023).
19 Adexon Team (2023) RIBA accredited CPD course, LinkedIn. Available at: https://lnkd.in/e8RrY3Q6 (Accessed: 09 November 2023).
20 Adexon Team (2023) Fire safety insights, Adexon Newsletter. Available at: https://bit.ly/AdexonNews (Accessed: 09 November 2023).
21 Adexon Team (2023) BS 8524-1: A conflicting national standard that should be formally withdrawn – and the improvements it needed. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/articles/bs-8524-1-a-conflicting-national-standard/ (Accessed: 21 November 2023).
22 Adexon Team (2023) Every question answered: Do operable fabric curtains (fire curtains) need to be CE marked?, Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/white-papers/every-question-answered/ (Accessed: 29 December 2023).
23 Adexon Team (2023) The quiet transformation happening in the fire curtain industry (2023) Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/articles/the-quiet-transformation-happening-in-the-fire-curtain-industry/ (Accessed: 29 December 2023).
24 AJ Retrofit Live 2023 (2023) Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/events/aj-retrofit-live-2023/ (Accessed: 03 January 2024).
25 Fire safety design 2023 (2023) Adexon. Available at: https://www.adexon-uk.com/events/fire-safety-design-2023/ (Accessed: 03 January 2024).